Munish Sood
Mandi
Himachal minister’s Assembly statement sparks BJP outrage; Jai Ram Thakur demands expunction, Kargil war veteran seeks apology; Negi accuses BJP of twisting his remarks
A controversial statement by Himachal Pradesh Revenue Minister Jagat Singh Negi on Operation Sindoor has triggered a major political storm, with the BJP launching a fierce attack on the Congress government and accusing the minister of undermining the valour of the Indian armed forces. The controversy, which erupted during the ongoing winter session of the Himachal Pradesh Assembly, has now escalated into a heated political confrontation over national security, military pride and the conduct of elected representatives.
The flashpoint came during a discussion on corruption after the BJP moved an adjournment motion under Rule 67 of the Assembly’s Rules of Procedure. While participating in the debate, Negi raised questions over the Rafale fighter aircraft procurement deal, alleging that an aircraft which was earlier priced at around Rs 700 crore was purchased for Rs 2,300 crore.
In the same context, the minister made the remark that Pakistan had given India a tough time during Operation Sindoor. The statement immediately triggered strong objections from the opposition, turning the Assembly debate into a politically charged confrontation.
BJP demands removal of remarks, Jai Ram Thakur warns of further action
Leader of Opposition and former Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur demanded that Negi’s controversial remarks be expunged from the Assembly records. Speaking to NDTV, Thakur said the BJP had already raised the demand and made it clear that the party would consider all available options if the statement was not removed from the proceedings.
Senior BJP leader Vipin Singh Parmar launched a sharp attack on the minister, questioning his understanding of the issue. He said the country was proud of its armed forces, which had struck terrorists at the very place where they had conspired to destroy the lives and families of innocent Indian tourists.
Former Himachal minister Sudhir Sharma, who left the Congress to join the BJP, also strongly condemned Negi’s statement. Taking a sharp dig at the minister, Sharma remarked that if Negi genuinely believed what he had said, he should go directly to Lahore.
Pointing out Himachal Pradesh’s deep-rooted military tradition, Sharma said nearly every third household in the state had someone associated with the armed forces. He termed the minister’s remarks deeply objectionable and said such statements hurt the sentiments of serving soldiers, veterans and families who had made immense sacrifices for the country.
Sharma further alleged that the Congress was attempting to regain lost political ground through controversial statements, both at the national and state levels.
Negi accuses BJP of twisting his statement
Facing mounting criticism, Jagat Singh Negi rejected the BJP’s allegations and accused the opposition of deliberately distorting his remarks for political gains.
The minister said the proceedings of the Assembly were fully recorded and argued that the BJP was attempting to divert attention from the original discussion on corruption by linking his statement to the armed forces.
Reading out his remarks before the media, Negi maintained that his comments were directed at the Rafale procurement deal and the aircraft’s performance during Operation Sindoor. He asserted that he had neither questioned the courage of Indian soldiers nor made any remarks against the valour and sacrifices of the armed forces.
Accusing the BJP of using the armed forces as a shield for political gains, Negi insisted that his statement had been presented out of context.
Meanwhile, Public Works Minister Vikramaditya Singh chose not to elaborate on the controversy when questioned by NDTV. He simply remarked that everyone was aware of the reality.
Kargil war veteran demands immediate apology
The controversy also drew a strong reaction from retired Brigadier Kushal Thakur, a veteran of the Kargil War, who termed the minister’s remarks inside the Assembly inappropriate and unacceptable.
Thakur said statements of this nature could adversely affect the morale of the armed forces and amounted to disrespect towards the sacrifices made by soldiers. Demanding an immediate apology from Negi, he also questioned the silence of the Congress leadership and the state government, calling for action against the minister.
With the BJP demanding the removal of the remarks from the Assembly records and Negi refusing to accept the opposition’s interpretation, the controversy has emerged as a major political flashpoint in Himachal Pradesh.
Beyond the immediate confrontation between the Congress and the BJP, the episode has brought the sensitive issue of political discourse surrounding military operations and the sacrifices of India’s armed forces into sharp focus.
