‘Lack of System Knowledge’? : CS's 'Party Culture' Remark Sparks Backlash

Shimla: A recent remark by Himachal Pradesh Chief Secretary Prabodh Saxena has ignited public criticism after he reportedly responded, “All of them (Chief Minister, Governor) keep hosting parties,” when questioned about a Holi celebration bill amounting to ₹1.22 lakh, submitted for government clearance.

His video is going viral and the controversy has triggered concerns over the use of public resources, especially in a financially distressed state.

This issue was first reported by journalist Devender Heeta in the national daily Dainik Bhaskar, who highlighted the questionable optics and fiscal ethics of such expenditures. His reporting struck a chord with a wide section of society, prompting a wave of reactions online — from senior journalists to social activists and common citizens.

Saxena’s follow-up comment, stating that “those who lack understanding of the system” are the ones raising such issues, only deepened the backlash. Prominent voices like Sanjeev Sharma (Punjab Kesari) and Navneet Sharma (Dainik Jagran) took to social media to express disappointment and concern, with many questioning whether such statements reflect a growing disconnect between the bureaucracy and the public they are meant to serve.

Beyond the cost of one party, the outrage reflects broader anxieties. Himachal Pradesh is burdened with over ₹1 lakh crore in public debt. Contractors await payment, youth unemployment continues to rise, healthcare infrastructure remains under strain, and essential welfare schemes like Sahara and Himcare are plagued with delays.

In such a scenario, images and reports of top officials hosting social events — funded or facilitated by state resources — have become symbols of misaligned priorities.

Constitutionally, the government is mandated to uphold economic, political, and social justice — not indulge in extravagance at the cost of public perception. When those in power appear to celebrate while citizens face hardship, the trust deficit only widens.

Importantly, this controversy transcends party lines. It highlights a systemic issue — where protocol often takes precedence over public accountability. In the digital age, where every word and action faces public scrutiny, citizens are not just passive observers but vocal stakeholders demanding responsibility.

S Gopal Puri